The High Court of Justice of Catalonia (TSJC) has annulled the valuation for the Casa Buenos Aires expropriation. Consequently, Barcelona City Council must now recalculate the compensation due to the former owners. The ruling invalidates the previous price of €4.2 million. Moreover, it states the assessment criteria did not reflect the property’s reality. The city previously addressed similar concerns in its broader public housing expansion strategy.
While the court’s decision does not challenge the expropriation itself, it demands a reassessment of the financial compensation. The aim is to convert the historic Vallvidrera building into social housing. Therefore, the recalculation is expected to result in a higher cost for the municipal administration. The city previously addressed similar concerns regarding the worsening housing crisis in Catalonia.
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home » Casa Buenos Aires Expropriation: Court Orders New Price Recalculation
Casa Buenos Aires Expropriation: Valuation Criteria Dispute
The core dispute lies in the property’s classification during valuation. The Expropriation Jury of Catalonia treated the building as a single-family home in 2022. However, the TSJC upheld the argument that this classification was inaccurate. The city previously examined similar valuation issues with innovative senior housing models like cohousing.
According to the ruling, the property’s history supports a different categorization. Although it briefly operated as a hotel in the late 19th century, it has primarily served collective purposes. These include use as a student residence, a geriatric centre, and a religious facility.
The judgement states that “the use most adjusted to reality is that of a multi-family residential building.” This rejects the single-family classification. Furthermore, this distinction is legally significant. It alters the variables used in both the comparison and residual valuation methods.
Financial Implications of the Casa Buenos Aires Expropriation
The court has ordered a “retroaction of the proceedings.” This means the calculation must be performed again using corrected multi-family criteria. While the sentence does not stipulate a specific new figure, the change suggests the final compensation will exceed €4.2 million.
Barcelona City Council initially estimated the Casa Buenos Aires expropriation would cost approximately €3.5 million. Opposition parties warned that prolonged litigation could inflate the final price. Following this ruling, municipal legal services have requested clarification. However, the final amount remains pending until the Expropriation Jury issues a new resolution.
A Symbol of Neighbourhood Struggle
The modernist building on Carrer Mont d’Orsà has been at the centre of a complex legal and social battle. In 2019, Casa Buenos Aires became a symbol of local activism. It was occupied by a youth group aiming to prevent its conversion into a luxury hotel.
Following the activists’ eviction in 2020, the City Council moved to expropriate the property. The goal is to preserve its architectural value and repurpose it for public use. The current plan involves creating 37 social housing units for elderly people and young adults. Additionally, it includes new neighbourhood facilities. While the project continues, the financial resolution of the acquisition is now back with the valuers.
Join Barcelona English Speakers WhatsApp Community .
