Spain’s Congress of Deputies narrowly defeated a contentious bill proposed by the far-right party Vox, which sought to ban full-face veils, such as the burqa and niqab, in all public spaces. Junts per Catalunya, a Catalan pro-independence party, cast the decisive ‘no’ vote, rejecting the proposal on Tuesday by 177 to 170, with one abstention.

Your browser does not support the video tag.

Vox championed this initiative, backed by the conservative People’s Party (PP). It sought a sweeping prohibition on garments that conceal a person’s identity in public areas. The party argued for the ban, stating it was necessary to protect women’s dignity and address public security concerns. The proposed legislation included severe penalties, such as fines and potential prison sentences for individuals who forced women to wear a veil. It even allowed for expulsion from Spain for serious or repeated offences.

A Paradoxical Veto

The bill’s defeat hinged on unexpected opposition from Junts, a party that paradoxically shares Vox’s objective of restricting full-face veils. In a surprising political manoeuvre, Junts voted against the bill, stating it was poorly constructed and legally unviable, and would not pass “any European filter.”

The same day Vox’s bill was struck down, Junts registered its own alternative proposal. Described as aligned with European legal standards, the party’s version takes a different approach. Reports from Catalan News indicate the Junts initiative focuses primarily on public identification, avoiding a specific system of fines. Instead, it would rely on existing disobedience laws for enforcement and, crucially, seeks to avoid criminalising women coerced into wearing such garments. The party confidently expressed that its more moderate bill could gain Socialist Party support without lengthy negotiations.

A Divisive National Debate

The Madrid debate highlighted deep divisions surrounding identity, religion, and security in Spain. During the fiery congressional session, Vox leader Santiago Abascal accused Catalan pro-independence parties of prioritising what he termed an “Islamic republic” over women’s freedom.

However, prominent government figures warned of the ban’s legal and constitutional pitfalls. Second Deputy Prime Minister Yolanda Díaz cautioned that prohibiting the burqa could violate Spain’s Constitution, which protects against discrimination and guarantees religious freedom. The debate has also resonated at municipal and regional levels.

“It’s a debate that must be addressed,” said Barcelona Mayor Jaume Collboni in an interview with RTVE, adding that he does not like the burqa, which he described as a way of “denying a woman’s identity.”

While the mayor believes public use of the burqa should be regulated, he cautioned that an outright ban “wouldn’t achieve the goal” of allowing women to choose how they dress. As Barna.News recently reported, Collboni previously backed burqa regulation in Barcelona, stirring local debate.

Catalan Government Calls for Calm

The Catalan government has indicated willingness to discuss the issue, acknowledging it “generates social unease.” However, spokesperson Sílvia Paneque insisted any dialogue must occur under “calm and rigorous conditions,” free from the “political opportunism” and confrontation she believes characterises current proposals from Vox and Junts.

With Vox’s hardline bill defeated and Junts’ alternative now tabled, the future of a full-face veil ban in Spain remains uncertain. The split vote reveals a complex political landscape where even parties with similar end goals are fiercely divided on the means to achieve them, leaving this sensitive issue in legislative limbo.